Judge 1
Originality – 5 Points
- the design is innovative (new and original)
- the design is unique (different from other designs we have seen in the past)
Cleanliness of Application – 10 Points
- the design is neat and clean
- the application is glue free
- the cuticles are free from design and glue
Design– 10 Points
- the design is well thought out
- the detail of design is clean and precise
- the design has adequate detail
Workmanship – 10 Points
- the overall quality of the work demonstrates outstanding artistic skills
- the workmanship is neat, clean and precise
Judge 2
Balance – 5 Points
- various elements of the design are well-balanced, neither too sparse or too busy
- the sum of the design is in harmony with the parts of the whole design
Creativity – 10 Points
- the design is well thought out
- the elements are used well
- the elements are used in a unique and different way
Visual Interest – 10 Points
- the design captures your attention
- the design holds your attention
Shape – 5 Points
- the shape is symmetrical and consistent individually
- the shape is symmetrical and consistent together as a set
Judge 3
Complexity – 10 Points
- the design is challenging, demanding skill and effort
- the design involves multiple techniques
Brightness – 10 Points
- the elements enhance the design
- the design is bright and clean
Detail – 5 Points
- the detail clarifies the design, adding dimension
- the design has adequate detail
Overall Impression – 10 Points
- the design makes an excellent overall impression
- the design is complete and needs no improvement
- this design is presented within the guidelines of the IAB rules